Did anybody refute A. Victor Garaffa article on Paul?

[Quahom1]

Originally Posted by Dor

Thanks Q I didnt think to ask that.

Ohhhh, how stupid and blind I was!

"Our Father, who art in heaven, hallowed be thy name..."

[Dream]

Is the challenge still good, and who will guarantee it? Its been a couple years since Victor's article was posted. I read his summary and think its very contestable. Its tedious though, and flowery, and long. So how do I know I would get my rebuttal published in the articles section, and under what specific conditions?

Proverbs 20:30 Blows that wound cleanse away evil; strokes make clean the innermost parts.

[Dondi]

I had a notion of writing up such an article, a point by point refutation. However a task like this, while feasible in my mind, would take considerable time to undertake, seeing it is such a long article. And would promise to be twice as long in countering a defense. Right now, there are just too many items on my plate to be committed to such an endeavor. However, I might be persuaded to contribute in a group effort, if there are those willing to do so.

[Dream]

That's an interesting idea, Dondi. You could begin by writing some about your main argument and try to show me where you want to go with it, and then I could write some things as a shadow writer. Some others might do the same, but I suggest having a single editor. I don't want to get cited as the author of a group project, so thanks for volunteering. The end result would represent your opinions and not necessarily ours, but it might be a good experience. It still would cost you some time, and a rebuttal to this is not really necessary, however you'd get an article slot.

[juantoo3]

If it would help ya'll any:

Refutation of Pauline Controversy

I already wrote a response to Mr. Garaffa's article, and bumped it too for his return. Perhaps you might like to pick up where I left off?

[Dondi]

Thanks juan. I forgot what I had said some of the posts on that one. I've hope revived it with a new post. I hope Victor will respond.