|
||||||||
|
|||||||
| Belief and Spirituality General thinking beyond the boundaries of religion and organised belief |
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
|
|
#16 (permalink) | |
|
UNeyeR1
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Maryland
Posts: 5,612
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Quote:
I am not trying to integrate reincarnation into Christianity....that was done long before this incarnation. As for once a Catholic always a Catholic, the second largest denomination of Christians is non-practicing Catholics....and they are in every denomination! As for what you incarnate as...steps forward, steps back...I just related in the non-duality thread how a huge step back in my life meant a huge step forward...I can see how there is learning to be had in all of creation, in any incarnation...and foundations developed in subconscious that will continue to benefit in the future. I don't see one forgetting everything...maybe consciously forgetting much...but subconsciously it is there....hence amazing mathematicians, musicians, etc. that are wise beyond their years...as kids they know more than folks that spend their lifetime in studies.... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#17 (permalink) |
|
Executive Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Westmorland, California
Posts: 760
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Wil,
You said, "...speaking to those Brazilian Catholics, reincarnation is very much part of their belief system, and fully accepted by the religious hierarchy."--> Wow, I did not know that. Thanks for sharing that. I am glad to see Thomas-like prohibitions are growing fewer and fewer. Progress is being made! I am also fascinated by the question of Catholics being reincarnated as Baptists, and vice versa. I am sure it happens all the time. Fortunately, each such "cross-over reincarnation" will help increase tolerance on both sides of the cross-over. |
|
|
|
|
|
#18 (permalink) | |
|
Will you also go away?
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 2,201
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Quote:
Christianity, and the Abrahamic Traditions, who believe in the Revelation of a Personal God — a God who 'relates' in an Immanent way with His creature — a God who knows and can be known ('personal' is a poor term to describe an ineffable mystery) treat the idea of Divine Union as precisely that, a Union of 'I' and 'Thou' that is the Supreme Gift of God. The idea of a being moving through a succession of 'I's (which would require the 'I' to be contingent and relative to some meta-nature that the 'I' is a manifestation of) then becomes untenable Scripturally and metaphysically — as God wills that each man be saved, not that a given number of souls can be abandoned as some indeterminate meta-soul moves towards a supposed perfection ... ... in the same way we do not view the soul as something distinct and separate from the body, but rather that the body is the soul manifest in corporeal terms ... ... without going into detail, there's a raft of philosophical and metaphysical reasons why reincarnation is untenable in the Christian metaphysics. If you want more data, I've referenced a raft of sources above ... Origen's a good one, as he seems liked by Theosophists, and refuted the notion on more than one occasion. There is the doctrine of reincarnation, and the doctrine of resurrection. The two are incompatible, we are founded on the latter. Thomas |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#22 (permalink) | |
|
that's my Boss in the pic
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: England
Posts: 209
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Quote:
Either we are given Love of God by the grace of Jesus in this lifetime, and (hopefully) go on to a Heavenly realm in God's company after death [I'm assuming this is near enough a correct overview] - Or in the reincarnation model we have to keep coming back and practicing following Jesus's teachings again and again untill through his grace and our endeavour we obtain such a state of pure Love of God that we are allowed into God's Kingdom, from where we will not return again to this earthly world. In this model we loose conscious memory of our past lives, but keep in our heart whatever spiritual lessons we learn along the way (as mentioned by Wil). I can see the argument of rejecting reincarnation based on scriptural evidence, but don't understand why logically it would cause any issues with the basics of what Jesus actually taught? Best Wishes, .... Neemai ![]() |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#23 (permalink) | ||
|
Executive Member
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Trans-Himalayas
Posts: 762
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Dear Dondi,
>Why on earth would I, as a Christian, who has found that spiritual >connection to God, would want to >come back here if I've already found >what I was looking for? For reasons of perfecting your being. Do you really think one small life is enough experience for eternity? And why would you be lollygagging around in Heaven for Eternity? Really, that is a Luciferic wish not a Christian one. We enter Heaven for rest and recreation and return to Mother Earth refreshed. >For that matter, someone in any religion who has found God or the >Ultimate, need not return to seek >Him all over again. And why would we venture forth to begin with? >It would be pointless foor our memories to be wiped clean after already >found the Answer to grope >again for the Answer all over again. That was just a temporary measure; increasingly will find that folk are remembering their former earth lives. Thanks be to Our Dear Christ and Our Loving Father God that we are granted the blessing of reincarnation. This blessing will enable us to go forward to perfect our beings in His Holy Name. We have the teaching from the Holy Scriptures which describe the time we spend out of incarnation as one thousand years: Quote:
Quote:
Your Servant in the Lord, Br.Bruce |
||
|
|
|
|
|
#24 (permalink) | |||||
|
Executive Member
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Southern Maryland
Posts: 1,970
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Quote:
I, for one, do not believe that we would be lounging around in the clouds plucking harps all day. There is a whole vast universe to explore, if not other planes of dimensions that will more than occupy our time, other peoples in other worlds perhaps. Not to mention learning fromevery other person who has made it to heaven, can you imagine how many? And what stories they have to tell. We are limited in our existence here. I believe when we don new clothes, so to speak, our minds and bodies will be able to do see, hear, taste, touch, feel, do things we never dreamed before, unlike these earthbound shells we inhabit now. Sounds and music unimaginable. Food that makes finest cruisine here taste like crap. Colors and sights to behold. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
But we have only a short time, as verse 10 explains: "The days of our years are threescore years and ten, or even by reason of strength fourscore years; yet is their pride but travail and vanity; for it is speedily gone, and we fly away." - Psalm 90:10 |
|||||
|
|
|
|
|
#25 (permalink) |
|
ex-member
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 641
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Consider the words of the Nazarene Master ... or His thoughts on Re-Birth, at any rate, faithfully communicated to us by a beloved disciple during the 20th Century:
And as we still wandered we came to a cottage before which sat an old man, and on his knee was a Bible in which he was reading intently.Now the errors of the centuries, this karma, falls upon those whose special responsibility it is to UNDO the corruption that has occurred ... and some of this can be done simply by allowing error to fall away. And some of this must be done especially by blending what is right, and sound, and useful in the teaching extant, with that which is Ageless and Eternally true, but somewhat new of form ... whether known & taught in the East, or only more recently, in the West. And a third type of Teaching has emerged, and that is what stands on its own, as it were, being closer still to that which a Teacher such as Jesus, or the Buddha, originally sought to deliver, but which was corrupted even in the very day of its deliverance, owing to faulty receipt ... by its audience. The last type of teaching includes much of the Ageless Wisdom Teaching as it has been presented since the days of the Theosophical Society hence. But a Christian need not be a Theosophist, in order to know and love his God. And he does not need to view the Christ in a presentation altogether unfamiliar to him in order to Serve God in the way that a Theosophist does, or a Buddhist does, or a Muslim does. We must each use the tools that have been provided us, while not forgetting that to some, the special duty of preparing the way has been assigned ... and these - you may be sure - will be ever vigilant to guard the Teaching against the false messiahs, the vain imposters, and those who love to stand in the synagogue, and shout & chant their prayers aloud. Some, most perhaps, work unnoticed and unseen. Others will bear the sharp criticisms of the tongues of the unknowing, be this the harsh words of the fearful and the unkind, or the challenges of the skeptics, the doubters, and the `spiritual materialists.' But we do not wish to be martyrs, and we would as soon meet our Brothers with a smile, and be met likewise, as with frowns of consternation ... and constant, bitter attacks against the Truth - which we Know and Serve. Love and Light, ~Andrew Master Jesus - by David Anrias The Lord Maitreya - by David Anrias |
|
|
|
|
|
#26 (permalink) | ||
|
Executive Member
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Trans-Himalayas
Posts: 762
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
>Don't be so limited in you thinking, Bruce.
Hmmmm, I don't get that comment often. ![]() > Not to mention learning fromevery other person who has made it to >heaven, can you imagine how many? And what stories they have to tell. Our Father's House has many Mansions. >We are limited in our existence here. I believe when we don new clothes, >so to speak, our minds and bodies will be able to do see, hear, taste, >touch, feel, do things we never dreamed before, unlike these earthbound shells we inhabit now. Ah, so you do believe in reincarnation, only not back here. I suspected as much. Moving from one body to another is reincarnation. I do believe in the Final Judgment and Resurrection BTW. >Sounds and music unimaginable. That can happen here on Earth. >Food that makes finest cruisine here taste >like crap. Colors and sights to >behold. You won't need to eat anyway. >Jesus has a resurrected body that could do things that a normal human >couldn't. Jesus as an Archetype set the way for the rest of us. >Why would I want to trade something like that for one that will cause pain? Pain serves a purpose. Intolerable pain is another thing- it really should not have been part of the Plan. >But we have only a short time, as verse 10 explains: Quote:
Here it is in Young's literal: Days of our years, in them [are] seventy years, And if, by reason of might, eighty years, Yet [is] their enlargement labour and vanity, For it hath been cut off hastily, and we fly away. Yes, hastily are we cut off. Too hastily for a mature development. What about those who don't get anywhere near the three score and ten? Young's literal Quote:
Why is the "thousand years" inserted there after "Turn back"? Best Wishes, Br.Bruce |
||
|
|
|
|
|
#27 (permalink) | |
|
Executive Member
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Trans-Himalayas
Posts: 762
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Karma is literally the protector of our being- as you sow, so shall you reap.
In order to fit this in with the conceptions of Original Sin and Grace, this lecture is helpful: Quote:
Br.Bruce |
|
|
|
|
|
|
#28 (permalink) | ||
|
Will you also go away?
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 2,201
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Hi Neemai —
Quote:
Quote:
Western cosmological religions speak of the 'immortality' of the soul in reference to the 'immortality' of the cosmos. Christianity, which transcends cosmology, speaks of the soul entering eternity — am aspect of the beatific vision. In the Christian vision immortality or eternity is not then a quality of the soul, were that so, then 'transcendence' would be meaningless, rather they are qualities of the Divine Life, into which the soul is drawn. Thanks for that brief but telling point about the differences between us. Contrary to what most would seem to think, I do not disaparage other religious traditions, in fact I delight in them — God is One, and Truth is One under God — but what I despair of is the tendency to ignore or discard the fundamental differences between them, the very thing that makes that tradition what it is, in the pursuit of what is essentially a sentimental ideal, that everything should be the same. Kurt Vonnegut wrote against such a notion brilliantly! Pax tecum, Thomas |
||
|
|
|
|
|
#29 (permalink) | ||
|
ex-member
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 641
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Quote:
The Eastern conception of the Soul is indeed, not like this Westernized presentation you are making. And yes, HERE is where we differ (you and I, you and every Esotericist I know, and you and you and most believers in Eastern Traditions) ... So, the Soul of Esotericism and of Hindu tradition, is quite unlike this thing you are talking about from within your Christian theology. It is indeed, of ONE Nature with the Divine. It is begotten, not made, as it is a future Christ, and is no different than was the current, `Spiritually Mature' Christ (as per Ephesians 4:13), at a certain prior stage of HIS development. In fact, looking but one, immediate `incarnation' in reverse, we find Lord Maitreya, your Christian Christ, stripped of all superstitutions and pageantries ... manifest to the devotee of India as Sri Krishna. And again, tradition and the religion of the people may have created of Sri Krishna something that Lord Maitreya can only partially claim as the plain & simple truth of historical fact, but then, that's what relgions are all about - as you are so keen to point out, Thomas. But the Soul, my friend, IS above corruption, for it is not an effervescence, some strange growth, an epiphenonmenal add-on to the limited, temporal personality, you and I. You see, it is an upside-down, EARTH-FIRST (and Heaven only second) philosophy and worldview ... a 180 degree orientation to the real state of things, which leads to the mistaken understanding that personality, or earthy ego, is the `real self' to begin with. And no amount of theologizing, no amount of mental wrangling, no subtle attempt to reverse the fact, will change that. To wit: Quote:
However, Christianity does NOT transcend the very Creative act, nor the Redemptive act(s), of the Creator God(s). You commit a logical error here, Thomas. You try to put Christianity on a pedestal, untouchable by Hinduism, or by Buddhism, even by Islam, Judaism, or other branches of a monotheistic religious mindset. And this is a form of elitism, not so subtle, I might add. Christianity may speak of the Beautific, the Divine, the Angelic ... but do not confuse MEANING with words on the page, Inspiration with SOUNDS uttered in praise or prayer, POWER with the thoughtforms and idea-forms which convey that current. And for a change, just imagine, this chitta which you so freely and willingly mold to YOUR will, YOUR desire, YOUR beck & call ... it answers the same, with respect to every other Soul on this planet. HENCE why the Buddhist focus on Bodhi-CHITTA, and thus also the prayers to the BODHI-SATTVA. This, then, is the true Christ, the only Christ which Reason, and the Law of God (which is LOVE) allows ... Maitreya means what again? Anyone happen to remember? We have, in every moment, the complete power of choice, as to whether, and as to how willingly, how gracefully, how lovingly and how considerately ... we will respond to the Divine Call, and cooperate with the Plan. Even if we only focus, for a moment, on GOD'S PLAN FOR US, we have already made a start. And then we may ask, what may be the Plan as regards those with whom I serve, those who are in my own social circle, those of like mind ... and interest. We will never respect another, so long as his path is wrong, and ours is right. Nor even, if his path is sufficient, close but `no cigar,' while ours is - supreme, highest, greatest, and all the best that God has to offer. I'm afraid all we do in such a case, is confuse our overblown-ego, with the faith which we cannot divorce from it, and by extension, it then becomes natural that nothing can touch ... what we have found. And what a shock we're in for, when we find that we live in a WORLD ... where yes, there is a Divine Hierarchy of Beings, as of purposes, plans, and also aims & agendas ... May God give us the Discernment to learn to know Cooperation, as also, difference(s) ... ~Andrew |
||
|
|
|
|
|
#30 (permalink) | ||||||||
|
Executive Member
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Southern Maryland
Posts: 1,970
|
Re: Christians are Free to Accept Reincarnation
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
And he that sat upon the throne said, Behold, I make all things new. And he said unto me, Write: for these words are true and faithful." - Revelation 21:4-5 Maybe pain serves a purpose down here, but pain will not be an issue in the Kingdom of God. Quote:
"A Prayer of Moses, the man of God. Lord, a habitation Thou -- Thou hast been, To us -- in generation and generation, Before mountains were brought forth, And Thou dost form the earth and the world, Even from age unto age Thou [art] God. Thou turnest man unto a bruised thing, And sayest, Turn back, ye sons of men. For a thousand years in Thine eyes [are] as yesterday, For it passeth on, yea, a watch by night. Thou hast inundated them, they are asleep, In the morning as grass he changeth. In the morning it flourisheth, and hath changed, At evening it is cut down, and hath withered. For we were consumed in Thine anger, And in Thy fury we have been troubled. Thou hast set our iniquities before Thee, Our hidden things at the light of Thy face, For all our days pined away in Thy wrath, We consumed our years as a meditation. Days of our years, in them [are] seventy years, And if, by reason of might, eighty years, Yet [is] their enlargement labour and vanity, For it hath been cut off hastily, and we fly away." - Psalm 90:1-10 [Young's Literal Translation] All I'm seeing here is a comparision between the eternalness of God in contrasted to the short lifespan of man. As a thousand years are nothing to God, He observes that conversely man is like the grass, here in the morning, but cut down in the evening. Why? Because our iniquities have set us against God, so our days are shortened: "For all our days pined away in Thy wrath, We consumed our years as a meditation." The "Turn back" part has nothing to do with reincarnation, but rather a call for the "sons of men" to repent from their sins. The wrath of God is the context of the Psalm: "Who knoweth the power of Thine anger? And according to Thy fear -- Thy wrath? To number our days aright let [us] know, And we bring the heart to wisdom. Turn back, O Jehovah, till when? And repent concerning Thy servants." - Psalm 90:11-13 If you are going to use the phrase "turn back" to denote reincarnation, then you would have to be consistent and say that Jehovah should be reincarnated according to verse 13. But that is simply not what it means. |
||||||||
|
|
|
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Why Christians should not accept Reincarnation: Pt 1 | Thomas | Christianity | 25 | 03-03-2007 07:18 PM |
| Why is it hard for Christians to accept Mohammad? | Seeker_of_truth | Christianity | 35 | 12-02-2006 05:21 PM |