Accusations Against the Baha`i Administration in India

[imranshaykh]

Originally Posted by Popeyesays

Imran,

You hijacked the last thread. I opened a thread for something you brought up, now you want to hijack this one away from its original intent.

What parallel thread? Where?

You need English classes. Read post #7 again. I did not want to hijack this thread. My thread is Islam and the Bahai Faith.

Regards,
Imran

[BruceDLimber]

Greetings!

Originally Posted by imranshaykh

The Quran was a proof for Prophet Mohammed in his lifetime as the Bible was for Jesus.

Incorrect:

Neither was compiled until years after Their deaths.

Peace,

Bruce

[arthra]

Hello Kiwi!

Say I was glad to read your post.... I saw on another board that you had become an Anglican priest! Is that for real or do I have my wires crossed????... I apologize if it is not the case..but there may be another Kiwimac out there...

Imran doesn't seem to accept that the Bab was the return of the twelfth Imam and I know this must be a burning issue for him...I think it deserves a separate topic but it was gone over a few months ago. I think he has a right to his views.

- Art

[Popeyesays]

Originally Posted by kiwimac

Seems a certain amount of defensiveness here. Which is a pity.

The Baha'i requirement for an 'independent search for truth' means, IMO anyway, asking questions that Baha'is might find offensive. But seeing that the independent search criteria are set by a manifestation of God, it is not a question of whether baha'is find it offensive but whether the question itself can be answered.

Kiwimac

Questions are never offensive, Kiwi. Genuine questions, anyway. Have you looked at Imran's website? Please, do, then judge if his questions are genuine.

Regards,
Scott

[Promethium]

Thanks to the independent investigation of of Popeyesays we were able to discern the truth of the matter as related to the topic of this thread.

[I, Brian]

Indeed, let's keep to the topic. I'd rather do positive things with the forum.

Topic is about the situation in India as reported, and how the case - if any - unravels.

Posts that follow on this thread discussing anything other than this subject may be removed.

[imranshaykh]

Originally Posted by Popeyesays

Questions are never offensive, Kiwi. Genuine questions, anyway. Have you looked at Imran's website? Please, do, then judge if his questions are genuine.

Regards,
Scott

"How is the Bab the Mahdi of Islam" Is this a genuine question or not?
But dont discuss it here for fear of hijacking this thread!

Regards, as always
Imran

[imranshaykh]

Originally Posted by BruceDLimber

Greetings!

Incorrect:
Neither was compiled until years after Their deaths.
Peace,
Bruce

Incorrect:

The Quran were present at the time of the Prophet (as). It was compiled and made into the present day Quran as we see it today after the lifetime of the Prophet.

Quran was revealed over 23 years. The Prophet identified each and every verse and indicated its position in the Chapters. The Chapters were not compiled by own own whims - they were done by the Prophet.

Bruce, can we take up this topic in any other thread? Please, I request you in earnest, please discuss only the accusations in India here or we will be accused of hijacking the thread.

Regards, as always
Imran